The guys do their Set Review for Eldritch Moon talking about the Top 20 Cards in the set as voted on by our Patrons of the show.

  1. Gisela, the Broken Blade
  2. Thalia, Heretic Cathar
  3. Tamiyo, Field Researcher
  4. Spell Queller
  5. Elder Deep-Fiend
  6. Liliana, the last hope
  7. Emrakul, the Promised End
  8. Eldritch Evolution
  9. Incendiary Flow
  10. Unsubstantiate
  11. Distended Mindbender
  12. Mausoleum Wanderer
  13. Bedlam Reveler
  14. Oath of Liliana
  15. Decimator of the Provinces
  16. Grim Flayer
  17. Scour the Laboratory
  18. Galvanic Bombardment
  19. Hanweir Garrison
  20. Murder

iTunes: Click Here

Facebook Group

Our goal is to always have Constructed Criticism be free of charge but we want to give fans who think what they hear is worth something a chance to contribute. So we have set up a Patreon page where you can go to support the cast. You can find the page here at

Check out our Sponsor at 5 Color Combo. 5 Color Combo is a great resource to find custom tokens, playmats or other accessories, learn more about Magic: The Gathering, and keep up with the latest news and strategies. They’ve also developed the premier app for getting better at limited, called Magic Drafter. Go to today!

A photo of Constructed Criticism Constructed Criticism

Our mission is to provide value and entertainment to the Magic: The Gathering community through our products, mtgs apps, articles, store, and services.